|
DMS with Workshare Professional |
DMS without Workshare Professional |
| Simplify Document Review |
| Review Management |
Simple and efficient parallel review
Undo applied changes
Repurpose documents as clean new master |
Single, typically serial review
Only accepted changes retained
Risk of artifacts from previous masters |
| Accuracy |
100% document comparison accuracy assured now with PDF compare |
Risky “stare and compare” |
| Gain Document Control |
| Identify Correct Master Document |
Automatic identification of review copies versus master
Single Master Tracking for multiple review copies
Automatic synchronization for “single” version of the truth |
All edited versions are “masters”
Potential for confusion with crossed emails / attachments
Proliferation of multiple documents at various states in review process |
| Audit Visibility |
Complete audit history including suggested changes
Audit of activity outside the perimeter |
No history of all suggested changes
No history of document activity outside the perimeter |
| Secure Document Exchange |
| Inside Perimeter Security |
Hidden data management cleans all prior edits, preventing unwanted discovery |
No hidden data management means higher risk of inadvertent disclosure of sensitive information
Must rely on authors to manage compliance and security rules |
| Outside Perimeter Security |
Policy based rules can be applied to assure nothing inappropriate leaves the firm/organization |
None |
| PDF Conversion |
Policy-driven and on demand |
None |
| Save Money and Resource |
| Training |
Task based user interface is easier to use
In-line with MS Office results in higher user adoption |
Extranets or collaboration sites are more difficult to learn, requiring extra training |
| Productivity |
Changes are easily accepted/rejected resulting in productivity for the user and review team.
DMS remains the repository
Automatic author delegation |
Final documents collated, copied and pasted into master document, introducing risk of corruption and error.
Multiple repositories—DMS, Outlook, extranet, Collaboration site (i.e. SharePoint)
Inability to delegate document tasks |
| Cost Savings |
Fewer review iterations mean increased productivity for review teams
Lower storage requirements for documents and email |
Additional review iterations, lowering productivity
Higher storage requirements for additional documents |